When church is hard
When church is hard
The silence that feels like judgment, the shame you carry in by yourself, and the quiet way a faith community can become the very place your story finally helps someone.
By Val & Bruce
There is a particular kind of walk. You have probably taken it. It is the walk from the car to the doors of your church — or your synagogue, your meeting, your circle — on the first morning after everyone knows. You rehearse your face in the parking lot. You decide where you will sit. You calculate which conversations you can survive and which ones you will need to slip past. And then you go in, certain that the thing that happened to you is written somewhere they can all read it.
We know that walk. We can tell you, gently, that some of what you are bracing for is real — and a great deal of it is not what you think it is. Both of those are worth saying plainly, because being honest about the hard parts is the only way the hopeful parts will be believed.
We had a name for it, in those first years. Walking from the car to the doors, one of us would mutter to the other, wearing the Scarlet D today — and the other would know exactly what was meant. The letter we were certain everyone could see, stitched onto us, announcing the one thing we most wished were not true. We said it half as a joke. It was not really a joke. It was the most honest shorthand we had for the whole weight of walking in.
So let us start with the thing almost no one names: in our experience, the harshest judge in the building was never another member. It was the one we brought in with us.
It was the first Sunday after my wife asked me to leave. I had moved into my sister’s basement, and I went to church that morning in her congregation, where no one knew me. I ended up in a class, and the teacher asked me to introduce myself. If I am honest, the thought of skirting the question crossed my mind — I could have given them the tidy version. But I had made a commitment to myself to be real. So I told them the truth: that my wife had asked me to move out, that I was living in my sister’s basement, and that she and I both knew it was probably not repairable. I did not say the next part out loud. But in my head, in the same breath, I heard myself think: Yes. I am that pathetic. That is shame. That is exactly what it sounds like.
There is a phrase we hear often in our church: No other success can compensate for failure in the home. In that season it played in my head on a loop, and I heard it as the sound of a gavel — the verdict that I had failed at the one thing that mattered most. I still get a small pain from those words sometimes; I am still working through it. They were never meant to do that to me. But that is what they did.
And underneath even that was a deeper fear. The verdict I was most afraid of was not the room’s, and not that phrase’s. It was God’s. I was sure I had let Him down. That I had disappointed Him. That somewhere in heaven there was a quiet, sorrowful if you had just been better.
I have come to believe something very different now. I believe He wept with me. I do not think He looked at my wreckage and shook His head. I think He was in every dark moment, closer than I knew, and that He helped me heal and find my way out in ways I may never fully understand. If shame is what you carry into that building — the fear that you have failed God Himself — this is the one thing I would most want you to hear. He is not disappointed in you. He is grieving with you. And He is already at work on your behalf.
— Bruce
When you are carrying that, you do not need anyone to actually judge you. You will hear judgment in a held glance, in a pause, in a friend who used to call and now does not quite know what to say. And here is what we eventually understood about those silences: most of them were not judgment at all.
They were awkwardness. People in a faith community value marriage and family; many of them have built their whole lives around it. When a marriage near them comes apart, they are genuinely disoriented. They do not know what to say, so they say nothing — and to a heart already convinced of its own guilt, nothing sounds exactly like a sentence being handed down. It usually was not. It was a good person standing at the edge of a grief they had no words for, afraid of saying the wrong thing, choosing silence over the risk of a wound. That silence still hurt. But it was not the verdict we heard in it.
We want to be careful and honest here, because pretending otherwise would not help you: sometimes the words are cruel. Sometimes they are meant to be. People take sides. They look for someone to blame. They say things that land like a slap, and a few of them mean to. We will not tell you that never happens, because it does, and if it has happened to you, we are sorry. It was not deserved.
But over the years we have come to see even those moments a little differently — not in a way that excuses the cruelty, but in a way that lets us set its weight down. A person who needs to wound someone who is already on the floor is almost always speaking from the pain in their own heart, not delivering a true account of yours. The harshness is a window into them, not a verdict on you. That does not erase the insult. But it can change what you do with it — whether you carry it home and let it confirm the worst thing you believe about yourself, or whether you can look at it and think, quietly, something must hurt in you, too.
Here is something we wish someone had said to us plainly, so we will say it to you. The first time you walk through those church doors, it is going to be hard. The first time you walk into work and someone asks how you are, it is going to be hard. The first holiday, the first family table, the first time you have to say the words out loud to someone who did not know — all of it is going to be hard. We are not going to pretend otherwise. But hard is not the same as impossible, and you have done hard things before. You have survived things you were sure you could not survive. You can do this one too. Not gracefully, maybe. Not without your hands shaking. But you can walk in. And the second time is always a little easier than the first.
We can say all of this with some authority, and not a little embarrassment, because we used to be on the other side of it.
I need to confess something. Before my own divorce, I was one of the most confident judges of divorce you could have met. I would not have called it judgment — I thought of it as standards. I had married someone good and faithful and smart, and somewhere underneath I believed that made me safe. I assumed that people whose marriages failed must have chosen poorly, or done something to deserve it. I had no idea — none — how many ways a marriage can quietly come apart while two people are doing their best.
And then it was my marriage. Judge not, that ye be not judged — I had read that verse a hundred times. I learned what it actually meant the hard way, because every harsh measure I had ever held up against someone else became the exact ruler I now used on myself. The despair I felt was, in part, my own old judgment turned around and pointed home.
I am not proud of who I was. But I am grateful for what it taught me, and for the grace that let me become someone kinder. It is the reason that today, when I meet someone in the middle of the worst of it, I have no interest in measuring them. I have been measured by that ruler. I would not wish it on anyone.
— Val
That experience left us with one commitment we hold more tightly than almost any other. When we meet someone in pain — or someone making choices we do not understand, or even choices we think are unwise — we try with everything we have to ask a different question. Not what is wrong with you, but what happened to you.
Those are two completely different questions, and they lead to two completely different responses. The first one measures. The second one listens. Almost everyone you will ever meet at church — including, on their worst days, the ones who hurt you — is carrying something that the second question would uncover and the first one never will. Learning to live inside that question is, we think, most of what it means to make peace with a community of imperfect people. It is also, not coincidentally, most of what it means to make peace with yourself.
None of this means the hard seasons are not real, or that you should rush back into a room that still aches. Healing takes the time it takes, and how much is deeply personal. For a while, you may need distance. That can be wisdom, not weakness.
But if you are standing at the edge of a bigger decision — whether to walk away from your faith altogether — we would ask just one thing of you, as a friend with a hand on your shoulder rather than someone leaning on you with doctrine. Try not to make a permanent decision from the middle of the pain. Wounds are honest, but they are poor long-term advisors. The choice is entirely yours; we are not here to talk you into a pew. We only hope you will make it one day from peace, and not from the worst week of your life — because a community of faith, for all the ways it can fumble exactly when you need it most, can also be the thing that carries you, and we would hate for one hard season to quietly cost you all of that.
We can tell you where this road went for us, because we did not believe it was possible when we were on the floor. These days we do not hide what we have been through. We are open about our divorces. We are never unkind about the people we were once married to. We try to love and serve the people around us. And the strangest, most unexpected thing has happened as a result: we feel completely welcomed. More than that —
People find us now. Quietly, usually — after a meeting, in a hallway, in a text that starts with can I ask you something kind of personal. The questions are almost always the same. You were divorced, right? So how are you so happy? What did you do? What is your secret?
We have had many of these conversations, and we love every one of them. We love the people in them. There is a line we often say, especially to each other: I just want everyone to be as happy as I am. What we have slowly realized is that we are not respected in our community in spite of having been divorced. In some quiet way, it is because of it. The very thing we were so sure had marked us turned out to be the thing that lets people trust us with the worst week of their own lives.
We would not wish the journey on anyone. But we are grateful for it — all of it. It made us more compassionate, more able to love, slower to judge, better at sitting with someone in the dark because we know the dark. We have a long way to go. But we are grateful for the road. And we promise you, from the far side of a walk that once felt unsurvivable: the thing you are most ashamed of today may become the most useful, most tender thing about you.
There is one more thing, and we almost did not notice it ourselves. Not long ago one of us said the old phrase out loud — the Scarlet D — and the other stopped, surprised, and realized we had not said it in years. We could not tell you when we stopped. There was no morning we decided we were done wearing it. It simply, at some point we never marked, stopped being true — and then stopped being said. That is what we want you to know more than almost anything else here. The letter you are so sure everyone can read today is not permanent. One day you will go looking for it and find that, somewhere back along the road, you set it down and walked on without it.
— Val & Bruce
So if church is hard right now — if the walk from the car still costs you something — we are not going to tell you it is easy, or that everyone will say the right thing, or that the ache disappears on a schedule. We will tell you this. The harshest judge in the building is probably the one you brought with you, and you can, with time and help, ask that one to be quiet. Most of the silence around you is fear, not condemnation. And one day, sooner than you would believe, someone is going to find you in a hallway and ask how you got to be so at peace — and you are going to have an answer.
There is a place set for you. It may not feel like it this morning. Walk in anyway, when you are ready. We will be glad you came.
When you’re ready, the next post is waiting.
The cows still have to be milked →
Browse the full collection →